Woodwork Woes, And What-Ifs

A well-worn statistic doing the rounds at present is that Liverpool have found the frame of the goal twenty-one times in their first twenty-eight league games this season. That figure is the joint most in the top five leagues in Europe, tied with Barcelona, according to whoscored.com. The fact that their opponents have only found their woodwork four times in the league this season further exacerbates the feeling that the Reds have been unlucky to not win a few more games

In a season when Liverpool only have 33 goals in their ‘For’ column, being inches away from a further 21 goals has made a massive difference to their points tally.

Or so you might think. Whilst it has had an impact, it’s probably not as pronounced as you would assume. I have broken down Liverpool’s woodwork stats further to try to quantify this.

For starters, eleven of the goal frame hits have occurred in matches that the Reds won anyway. Whilst the wins may have been more comfortable, and an improved goal difference is always welcome, in terms of actual league points a little over half of the woodwork strikes have had no bearing on the points tally at all. That leaves ten that might have made a difference.

Those ten are therefore spread across the seventeen league games that Liverpool have failed to win this season. In eleven of these matches, the Reds did not hit the post or bar, which appears to leave six games where striking the frame of the goal might have cost Liverpool further points.

As one of these games was a 3-1 defeat away at Bolton Wanderers though, and the frame of the goal was only struck once (meaning the Reds would still have lost even had the shot gone in) we are left with just five matches:

The stand out match from these five is the home draw with Norwich City; Liverpool put nine of their twenty-one shots on target that day, plus found the woodwork three times, yet had only the solitary goal (and point) to show for their efforts.

The matches with Sunderland and Swansea only have one goalframe strike apiece, and thinking back to those matches shows how much difference in likelihood of scoring there can be between woodwork hits; Stewart Downing hit the bar from long distance against the Mackems, and realistically would have done very well to score from where he took the shot, whereas Andy Carroll really should have found the net with a point-blank header six yards out against the Swans.

The really interesting cases are Fulham and Arsenal. At Craven Cottage, we can see there was one of the four occasions this season that the opposition have found the frame of the Liverpool goal, and that if all three woodwork strikes in that match were goals then it would have ended as a 2-2 draw.

Similarly, a narrow defeat at home to Arsenal recently might actually have been a narrow win had a couple of shots hit the post and gone in, rather than rebounding to safety from a Gunners’ perspective.

In total, in the unlikely scenario that all woodwork strikes actually went in, then Liverpool would have ten more points than they have now. That would put them in 4th position, level on points with Arsenal but ahead on goal difference.

I think this is an unrealistic assumption though, as all teams hit the woodwork every so often. Pure speculation now on my part, but from the figures above I think it’s reasonable to say that the Reds should’ve beaten Norwich, had a point from Fulham and Arsenal, and the other two draws you have to take on the chin. That would mean an extra four points, which is perhaps a little more realistic. But then I can point out here that Liverpool also missed penalties in the Sunderland and Arsenal games, so who knows what points they should really have had.

Of course, goals change games, and had Liverpool scored earlier (or indeed, at all) in the above five matches plus the Bolton defeat, then the results could very easily have swung in their favour.

But ultimately, with all the airing that the statistic regarding Liverpool’s woodwork woes gets, I was very surprised to see how few games it has really mattered in. That said, if the Reds finish within ten points of fourth spot, a big part of me will certainly now be thinking ‘what-if’ about this season.

Statistics sourced from EPLIndex. Please take a look at my other articles, a list of which can be found here.

3 thoughts on “Woodwork Woes, And What-Ifs

  1. Andrew,

    i) Way to taking away my favourite excuse for this season :/


    I think you’re spot on in your approach to breaking down strikes against the bar/post by importance. That gives it more meaning. Tomkins had done a fantastic piece, quite a while back, in which he broke down Kuyt’s goals by importance and got some downright mental numbers: in short, Kuyt ONLY scored important goals that season. I can’t find a link to that article but he had defined ‘important’ goals in a clever way.

    I think you might get a more meaningful conclusion from your analysis if you compared the points dropped by Liverpool this season because of the bar/post to that of other teams in the league (maybe the top 6 as a beginning).

    Off-topic Rambling

    Another angle would be to see how it disrupted consistency/momentum. That would require a study on the effect of consistency. No idea how you’d do any of this. I’m just thinking out loud. Consistency seems like the holy grail. Once you get that, it breeds more consistency which brings better results. When you’re struggling for it, there’s a reverse spiraling effect.

    A long shot might be to test the number of times a team has 2 negative results on the bounce. I bet a United or any of Mourinho’s teams in the last decade will have incredibly superior numbers to Liverpool. Again, rambling.


    • There has been lots of debate amongst the posters on The Tomkins Times recently about the realities of confidence, momentum and so on. I think it’s impossible to assess without doing months of research, and there’s so many things to consider (e.g. as teams tend to play home then away and so on, their chances of winning a game vary from week to week, and things like that).

      I agree a comparison of the points won/lost with the other teams would be interesting, might look into that at some point. It’s very time consuming though!

      Cheers for reading, appreciate it.

  2. Pingback: Woodwork Woes 2012/13 | Bass Tuned To Red

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s