Which Win At Old Trafford Is The Greater?

Following a fantastic 3-0 victory by Liverpool over Manchester United, the debate amongst Kopites has begun over whether this victory was better than the famous 4-1 win in 2008/09.

Whilst there is no way to settle it conclusively, I thought I’d take a quick look at the match stats and make a judgment that way.


Compared to 2009, Brendan Rodgers’ team had more possession, and were also more accurate in their passing (both in the United half, and in total).

Not only that, but the current Reds vintage had more shots (on target and in total) and created more chances than Rafa Benitez’ side too. This is particularly noteworthy, as Liverpool lead the latest match for ten minutes more than they did in the 2009 encounter, so you would perhaps expect them to have fewer shots this time around as the Red Devils spent longer trying to get back into the game (and losing teams tend to shoot more than winning ones).

It’s interesting to note that the 2014 Manchester United actually passed with greater accuracy than their 2009 counterparts, though it did them little good as they created fewer chances and had fewer shots. This is probably due to the central issue that undermines this comparison though: the varying merits and qualities of the four sides we’re looking at.

Even if we ignore the four managers involved, United went into the game in 2009 in first place in the league, with sixty-five points from twenty-seven games, as opposed to seventh with forty-eight points from their twenty-eight matches. There’s an obvious gulf in quality right there.

Liverpool’s position was essentially the same for both matches though: third in the league having played twenty-eight matches in both scenarios, with Rodgers having earned a single point more than Benitez had.

Clearly Liverpool were more likely to win this match than they were in March 2009, but then the stats suggest they performed better too. It is impossible to conclusively say which was better, but the numbers suggest that 4-1 flattered Liverpool in 2009 whereas the score this time around was merited. Which do you think was better?

Please check out my other articles, and follow me on Twitter, Facebook or LinkedIn. Scroll down to see the related posts for this article. Thanks.


2 thoughts on “Which Win At Old Trafford Is The Greater?

  1. I think maybe the visuals of less field goals last sunday, and MUFC being the underdogs (unlike previous encounters) made our performance unsurprising in the sense that it was expected we would get a good result.
    Manchester United defended abysmally and at times in a barbaric way, like in the fourth penalty we should have been awarded when Sturridge was swept off his two feet without even having ball possession. That didn’t help the spectacle, we would have had more field goals if United had decided to kick the ball instead.
    Maybe it feels slightly underwhelming compared to Rafa’s team achievement, but I believe that, come the end of the season, if we manage to get or scrap the title, this will still be remembered as one of our highest moments of the season for years to come.

  2. Personally i think the win this weekend gave me more satidfaction than the one in 2009, Yes United in 2009 were a better team than they are now granted! but still that on Sunday was a destruction, it showed we had class,ability and composure! were United fell too pieces! That showed what Liverpool are capable of and showed we are not scared of United at Old Trafford… Hell we are not scared of anyone anymore! The fact united played two holding midfield (at home may i add) against us showed straight away FEAR!

    Easily are best win thus far, they were well beat! long it may it continue! onwards and upwards reds!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s